C'mon....you giving instructions on health histories now?
You gonna cath someone based on parents history ALONE?
You gonna make them incur a risk of IMMEDIATE open heart surgery based on parent history ALONE?
Way to play to the straw man. Since this fundamental principal that we call reading
AND comprehending seems to have escaped you, let's review. Even though my post is only above yours, I will quote it here to better facilitate this elusive comprehension part.
I've taken a fair share of medical histories myself, and yes, your parents do enter into it.
YEs, parents health does enter into it. Hmmm...did I claim it is more important than any other factors? No. I didn't even attempt to classify them. Simply said that it is a factor.
Chest pains, just ate spicy food, father died of a heart attack at a young age,
This is fairly obvious. Several factors that you might have been presented with. And yes,
ALL should be considered. Remove one, and the whole Dx changes. Add others, it changes again.
you would be negligent to not move a coronary evaluation just a tad higher up your priority list.
I stand by this. If you are unwilling to look at the obvious familial history, you are a hack, and you should
NOT be treating the living.
You will notice that I never advocating cathing someone. Nor did I advocate surgery. What I did was correct your statement that family history is of no value in making a diagnosis. And yes, you were wrong. I understand that you, as a die hard Republican, are desperate to make your candidate look the best possible. I can't fault you for that. But it would be foolish to ignore the reality of his age and medical history. Especially in light of his VP choice having no international decision making experience. That experience is tough to come by, specially when you need a woman VP. If a physician were to ignore a family history of heart condition, and the patient were to suffer, yes, he would be negligent, and it would be actionable.
Normally you come across as pretty fair, and very smart. But I will take exception with your post here.
Edited to change wording.